home Worship Blog > Current Posts

A Worship Evangelism Reversal
User: randall wilkens
Date: 10/9/2007 5:49 pm
Views: 2992

Those of us who attended the 2007 Worship Connection event in Denver had the opportunity to hear Sally Morgenthaler, and many more of us have read her book Worship Evangelism.  The principles of that book have done a lot to shape worship ministry in contemporary churches in the beginning of this century. In various ways—whether we realize it or not—many of us have taken Sally’s advice when we have sought to make worship more culturally relevant and more accessible to the unchurched.

So when my colleague Chad McDaniel e-mailed me a link to a new article on “Worship as Evangelism” by Sally Morgenthaler, I figured I pretty much knew what she was going to say. But wow, was I wrong! Because instead of reiterating the principles outlined in her book, Morgenthaler basically confessed that it wasn’t working, and that she’s decided to get out of the “worship evangelism” business!

She says that worship evangelism isn’t working because most of the “church growth” we’ve seen in recent years is in megachurches that—rather than attracting the unchurched—have largely drawn from dying older churches and/or failed startups. She cites statistics that show not a rise, but a drop in American church attendance over the past 15 years. And perhaps the most compelling part of the article is a quote from a secular journalist’s report on his visit to a prominent megachurch, and this stark summary of what that journalist had to say:

“No sad songs. No angry songs. Songs about desperation, but none about despair. Worship for the perfect. The already arrived. The good-looking, inoffensive, and nice. No wonder the unchurched aren't interested.”

Troubling words! I knew this article would probably receive some equally troubled reactions. But my own reaction, to be honest, is one of relief. Finally, we can worship simply because God is worthy and not because of this evangelistic burden which worship was never meant to bear! And I think we may find, as we worship simply to seek the face of God, that our evangelism will be more empowered than it was before, coming from hearts of those who have been with the Savior we proclaim.

What are your thoughts? I encourage you to read the entire article, Worship As Evangelism.

And let’s discuss our reactions here.

Randall Wilkens

 


Randall Wilkens is Associate Pastor of Worship and the Arts at Bethany Covenant Church in Mount Vernon, Washington. He holds a Doctorate in Organ Performance from the University of Kansas and is a member of the Covenant Commission on Worship.

 

Read Randall's web article, The Organ in the 21st Century.

 

Re: A Worship Evangelism Reversal
User: Rev Dave
Date: 10/12/2007 12:59 pm
Views: 336

Randall,

Thanks for sharing the article (and your blog). I look forward to reading it.

 I think over the past several years, churches have struggled over whether to make worship welcoming to the unchurched/seeker or to tailor it to the members of the congregation. Each group has their own particular needs. And in trying to meet the needs of either (or both!) groups, we become trapped.

What if . . . what if worship wasn't a performance, but a response to the God who moves and acts in our daily lives? 

What if . . . what if we just focused on God and worshiping Him instead of trying to meet everyone's needs? Now I know that's maybe to trite of a solution. After all, we come with our emotions, our own differing experiences and conceptions of God. We come with different depths in our relationships (with God, with others), with different spiritual maturity. But if we just focused on worshiping our Creator, our Redeemer,our Indweller, wouldn't that attract people (assuming we worshiped authentically in spirit and in truth)?

What if . . . what if we actually believed (and lived out) that worship isn't just a church event, but a lifestyle? Isn't that where worship evangelism might come in?

I don't think worship evangelism needs to be a wrong idea--we maybe just need a better understanding of what each of those concepts needs to look and how they should interact.

In His Light,

David Wenell
Associate Pastor of Youth & Family Ministries
Emmanuel ECC, Surrey, BC

Re: A Worship Evangelism Reversal
User: Katherine Martinez
Date: 10/15/2007 4:26 pm
Views: 276

Hi Rev. Dave.

I like the way you put this: W.E. doesn't have to be a wrong idea, we just need good understanding of what those terms mean.

If Worship Evangelism means: Creating a warm "welcome" in worship, I like that. "Welcome" goes way beyond form and style. It's a whole culture that leaders and congregations either cultivate, or won't/don't have. 

I think it takes a lot of work, because our tendency is to curve in our ourselves rather than reach beyond. Given the commission of Christ, it seems that the "reach" should always be a part of our common life. Jesus reached, and that's why we're part of the faith he taught and passed to the disciples. Then they reached. 

I know we get it all mucked up, but I still think we've (the whole church) learned a lot about "reaching" through the seeker-sensitive 'movement'. I don't think we should be so hard on the church. We especially shouldn't judge our brothers and sisters-- church planters or whomever-- for worshiping 'wrong'.

There are many ways to skin the cat, eh?

Thanks Dave,

Katie 

Re: A Worship Evangelism Reversal
User: Rev Dave
Date: 10/16/2007 1:05 pm
Views: 245

Thanks for your words as well, Katie. "Authentic Worship" is a much better route than "Evangelism Worship."

I finally got a chance to read Sally Morgenthaler's article. It is very insightful. And she's right: we're not going to attract people for worship if we're not also being Jesus' hands and feet in our neighbourhood.

And that's where authentic worship comes in. If we're truly worshiping the Triune God and living a life of worship, it won't just be a Sunday morning (or Saturday night) event. If we're authentic in worshiping our Lord, we're going to be about reaching out as well; we're going to help those in need. That's what authentic worship leads to; that's what true worship is.

In His Light,

David Wenell
Associate Pastor of Youth & Family Ministries
Emmanuel ECC, Surrey, BC

Re: A Worship Evangelism Reversal
User: Katherine Martinez
Date: 10/16/2007 3:58 pm
Views: 267

Dave.

Maybe that's the linchpin that holds the matter. Worship in our sanctuaries must prompt a life response, or it's just an event. The event is important, because we experience God's presence in the company of the saints, and it helps us discern what God is saying and doing among us for the good of the world, and it's a grace filled experience that gives us confidence to do the work we're called to do...

Thanks Dave

Katie 

 

Re: A Worship Evangelism Reversal
User: brianwo
Date: 11/3/2007 9:03 am
Views: 170

I'm glad to see this thread, as I've been batting this subject around with my worship teams for a few weeks now, not only based upon this article, but a number of other things making me rethink our worship.  As Sally writes about how unchurched people are much less likely to step into our churches today, I resonate with David's comments that unchurched people will not come unless we are living out worship, being Jesus' hands and feet in our neighborhood.  So if unchurched people indeed join us in worship, our authenticity will be a key to inviting them in, as David also mentions.  So do we focus on seekers or believers, as Willow is asking right now?  I think we focus on engaging the people who are there, understanding how they can best offer authentic worship to the Lord.  Then, as Katie said, our worship prompts a response, and we come away transformed, living out our worship as a means of evangelism.

Brian Wo

Grace Community Covenant Church

Palo Alto, CA

Re: A Worship Evangelism Reversal
User: shouwen
Date: 1/8/2008 1:20 pm
Views: 142

Okay, so this is pretty late, but I haven't been on lately. I would like to add here that problems arise when Worship Evangelism, or Emergent Church or other programmatic (or anti-programmatic for that matter) approaches are taken with the specific goal of attracting people. Don't hear me saying I don't believe we should be thinking about that aspect, but when it becomes the sole focus, when the entire desire of a style is to get people in the doors, those people will quickly identify it as a marketing strategy and not as authentic. I am glad so many responses here have approached this "authentic" piece. Authentic worship directed to our triune God will be attractive to people, but that's not the point. The point is the worship. Authentic worship then, as others have said, is not a segregated portion of our lives. If we live lives of authentic worship, our everyday life of obedience to God will attract people to Him. As Romans 2:3-4 instructs, it is God's kindness that leads us to repentance. So, if we are authentic in our worship, the sense here being that it is part of our obedience to God, we will act in the lives of those around us, and that will lead not to our glory as worshipers, worship leaders etc., but to God's Glory and to the increase of His kingdom. After all, I think we are after kingdom level work before church membership. We need to escape the "PR" mindset accompanying much of church growth approaches and let God draw people to Him through our obedience in worship.

To obey is better than sacrifice, and to heed is better than the fat of rams.

1 Sam. 15:22                      

Steve

Life House Covenant Church

www.myspace.com/lhworship

PreviousNext






Click here to register.

facebook Share this page on facebook

Get the RSS Feed
RSS 2.0 Feed

 

Blogroll

The posts of bloggers do not necessarily reflect the The Evangelical Covenant Church. All posts are listed for discussion purposes only.

Covenant Blogs >> Unofficial listing of Covenant Bloggers

 

 

Who We Are · Local Churches & Conferences · Denominational Ministries · Institutional Ministries · Support Ministries · Outreach Ministries · Inicio
Copyright © September 6, 2008 The Evangelical Covenant Church. 5101 N Francisco Ave., Chicago IL 60625. 773-784-3000


Click here to register.